Connect with us

Hi, what are you looking for?

Article

Foundation President: Anyone With Money Can Give It Away. That Doesn’t Mean They’re Good at It

Philanthropy is far more difficult than many people think – including within the philanthropic sector itself. And if you do not take the craft seriously, you risk both missing opportunities for major impact and causing real harm, says Jen Ford Reedy, author of Please Be Good at Philanthropy.

“One of the things about our field is that anybody with money can do it,” says Jen Ford Reedy, President of the Bush Foundation. [Photo: Bush Foundation]

A woman in North Dakota became, quite unwittingly, a philanthropic muse for Jen Ford Reedy.

“Will you please tell other funders that they can’t give us $10,000 and ask us to show the impact that they have?” she pleaded.

The Bush Foundation had asked its grantees whether the foundation was doing a good job and what it should do differently.

And the woman’s plea stayed with Jen Ford Reedy. Because it captured something she had seen again and again during her 14 years as President of the Bush Foundation: unreasonable demands rooted in fundamentally mistaken ideas about philanthropy.

That simple plea became one of the forces that led Jen Ford Reedy to write a primer on a field that far too many people underestimate. With significant consequences.

She gave the book the title Please Be Good at Philanthropy.

Success Doesn’t Transfer

You can be an excellent chess player without necessarily being any good at table tennis, cooking or pottery.

In the same way, you can have built a profitable business with intelligence and skill and still have no idea how to do philanthropy well.

Key Takeaways

Philanthropy is a craft. Being successful in other fields does not automatically make someone a skilled philanthropist.

Philanthropic strategy differs from conventional organizational strategy because the foundation funds the work while other people carry it out.

A narrow strategic focus can cause foundations to overlook strong organizations and easier paths to greater impact.

Foundations can mistake the difficult and complex for the good — partly because the complicated solution makes their own role more visible.

A foundation can create enormous value simply by becoming really good at identifying where its money can make the biggest difference.

Foundations should think differently about risk: Their own organizational risk is often small, while grantees and the people they seek to serve may bear far greater consequences.

Jen Ford Reedy has watched successful people enter philanthropy believing they already have many of the answers. And she has watched them fail.

“I’ve experienced a frustration over the years of watching bad philanthropy — and particularly watching people new to the field come in with a bunch of swagger and believe it’s going to be easy, and then watching them be humbled over and over,” she says.

One of the peculiar things about philanthropy is that you can gain enormous influence without first having demonstrated that you have mastered the field. In principle, you simply need to have the money.

“One of the things about our field is that anybody with money can do it. So there are a lot of people where the moment they decide to turn their attention to philanthropy, they’re a huge philanthropist,” Jen Ford Reedy says.

But that says very little about their philanthropic competence.

“Being in a position to do philanthropy is almost entirely uncorrelated to any skills that would suggest you’re going to be good at doing philanthropy,” Jen Ford Reedy says.

Because philanthropy is not intuitive.

“You need to know things,” Jen Ford Reedy says.

Do we underestimate how difficult philanthropy actually is — perhaps especially among highly successful businesspeople?

“For sure,” she says.

“That’s something in the nature of some people’s personalities, and it’s something in the nature of all human beings. You know, believing that because you went to school, you know what it takes to run a good school.”

Philanthropy Is an Apprenticeship

The problem does not stop with the billionaire who suddenly decides to save the world.

Many people also learn philanthropy through a kind of apprenticeship, Jen Ford Reedy points out.

You join a foundation and learn its criteria, processes, grant cycles and board procedures. And in doing so, what you primarily learn is how that particular foundation operates.

“You come in and you learn your organization’s way of doing philanthropy,” Jen Ford Reedy says.

About the Bush Foundation

The Bush Foundation was founded in 1953 by Archibald “Archie” Bush and his wife, Edyth Bush.

Archie Bush began his career as a bookkeeper at Minnesota Mining and Manufacturing — later 3M — and rose through the company as his wealth grew. The couple established the foundation with 3M stock.

Today, the foundation primarily works in Minnesota, North Dakota and South Dakota, as well as with the 23 Native nations that share this geography. Its purpose is to inspire and support creative problem solving that can make the region better for everyone.

The risk is that you do not learn to see the foundation’s practices as a series of deliberate choices among several possible options, but instead as the very definition of philanthropy.

“We’ve all just accepted that philanthropy is something you learn by doing, or that philanthropy is not a particular skill set you have to teach,” she says.

Philanthropic Strategy Is Different

Jen Ford Reedy knows the world of conventional strategy from the inside. Before entering philanthropy, she spent nine years as a consultant at McKinsey & Company.

For her, philanthropy is about creating impact — fulfilling a purpose of doing good as effectively as possible.

That requires understanding philanthropic strategy, and especially how profoundly it differs from almost every other kind of strategy.

What is the most important difference?

“If you were going to say one thing that’s the most important difference, I think it’s that in philanthropy, you don’t control implementation,” she says.

In a company, management can decide to launch a new product, change the organization or start working in a different way.

“You tell the people who are working for you that they’re going to do that. You hire those people, you can fire those people, you give them feedback. You determine, these are our goals, and we’re going to make sure they happen one way or another,” Jen Ford Reedy says.

But philanthropy does not work that way.

“You give the money, somebody else does the work.”

That seemingly simple difference changes almost everything, according to Jen Ford Reedy.

“All of that ability to direct the human beings who are actually doing the work is gone,” she says.

Because a foundation cannot dictate implementation, it depends on being aligned with its grantees.

That can mean working with organizations that already want and are able to create the change the foundation also wants. In that case, the task is relatively straightforward.

The picture looks very different if a foundation defines a goal that no one else wants or is able to pursue — or whose importance only a few people have yet recognized. In that case, the foundation has given itself a much more difficult task.

And this is where the conventional understanding of strategy can actually become an obstacle.

When Focus Becomes a Trap

Take focus, for example.

“One of the most common bits of advice that foundations have gotten in the time that I’ve been in the field is: focus, focus. If you want to have an impact, you should be focused,” Jen Ford Reedy says.

It sounds logical, but:

“If you focus, focus, focus, and enough other people don’t want to focus exactly where you’re focusing, you may have a really, really hard job in front of you,” Jen Ford Reedy says.

At the same time, focus can work like a streetlight illuminating a limited area. Just beyond the pool of light may be strong organizations ready to create change.

“There might be a bunch of people working right here, really adjacent to what you want to do, that all they need is your money and they could go. But you can’t even see them because you have your blinders on for your narrow, narrow, narrow focus,” Jen Ford Reedy says.

The problem becomes particularly apparent when foundation boards start looking for gaps on the map.

An analysis may identify an issue or a geographic area where no one is working.

That may be a perfect strategic opportunity. But the absence of other actors can also be a warning sign, Jen Ford Reedy points out.

Yet she sees foundation boards make strategic decisions to enter an area before finding out whether there are actually people who want the work done and whether anyone has the capacity to do it.

“They make those strategic commitments without having that basic information: How hard is this going to be?” she says.

The Hard Way Feels Better

Jen Ford Reedy points to something that might be called complexity snobbery: philanthropists can actually be drawn to the difficult solution, even when an easier option could create more impact.

“I think some of it is related to not having very simple measures of our impact,” Jen Ford Reedy says.

A philanthropist wants to make a difference. That means emotions enter the picture.

“Doing something harder feels like you’ve had more impact than doing something easier, when quite often the easier thing could actually have had more impact,” she says.

Five Truths About Philanthropic Strategy

Jen Ford Reedy builds her thinking around five fundamental realities that she believes philanthropists need to understand:

Change is human, and often hard. Money can’t always help as much as we wish it could.

Grantmaking is giving away money — and control. Other people and organizations have to turn the money into action and results.

Others bear most of the risk. The foundation itself often bears very little of the real consequences.

Constraints are mostly self-imposed. Foundations have considerable freedom to act, but must make choices — and stick with them.

Impact can be super hard to define and measure. Big, transformational impact is often harder to measure than smaller impact.

You see it, for example, when a foundation has come up with an idea itself, developed the intervention, brought the actors together and fought to make it happen. In that situation, it is easy to see your own importance.

Jen Ford Reedy illustrates the thinking with a foundation that develops a new principal-training program intended to improve student achievement.

If it succeeds, it will feel amazing. But getting all the parties on board has also been hard work.

Now imagine instead that the idea comes from a local school district. The right people are in place. The expertise is there. Everyone is ready.

The only thing missing is money. So the foundation writes the check. And achieves the same positive results.

“The impact you had was the same, and return on impact — how much good happened relative to how much effort and money you put in — is actually better in the other example,” Jen Ford Reedy says.

“But you don’t feel as responsible for it.”

When the foundation chooses the difficult route, it also gains a greater sense of ownership. It can look at the result with pride and see its own hand in it.

“For a lot of people, the hard way feels good because it feels more like, ‘This couldn’t have happened without us,’” Jen Ford Reedy says.

And right there, a misconception arises that can have major consequences.

“It’s really easy because of that to mistake hard philanthropy for good philanthropy,” she says.

So do we miss a lot of opportunities because of that?

“Yeah, I do. I absolutely do.”

Getting Good at Giving Money

That leads to a paradox: foundations tend to undervalue their most obvious contribution — money.

“Sometimes I do think we undervalue the grantmaking part. And I don’t know whether it’s because we’re sheepish that we have money, but we don’t feel like just giving the money was that much of a contribution,” she says.

But in many cases, money is exactly the ingredient that is missing to make something happen.

“If everything else was lined up, people were already excited about it, people were ready to go, and all we did was give money, you were still an essential ingredient because all those people lined up to go do that thing couldn’t do it without money,” Jen Ford Reedy says.

That leads her to identify a skill that sounds less glamorous than developing sweeping new strategies:

“Being great at spotting those opportunities where money can make the biggest difference is in itself perhaps the most important philanthropic skill,” Jen Ford Reedy says.

The skilled philanthropist does not have to be the person who invents the solution. They can be the person who recognizes it.

Another way to get good at giving money is what Jen Ford Reedy calls functional philanthropy.

Instead of constantly reinventing the wheel in ever more elaborate forms, a foundation can become genuinely good at one particular function and apply that expertise across issues and organizations.

It might be helping organizations strengthen their advocacy. It might be technology. Or something else entirely. The point is that the foundation develops real expertise.

“Then I think you have the opportunity to bring more value from one organization to another, because you’ve actually gotten really good at something,” Jen Ford Reedy says.

And perhaps even more importantly:

“You’re an expert at something that isn’t in conflict with what the grantee organization is expert in.”

Other People Bear the Risk

But missed opportunities are one thing. It is another when foundations launch solutions with unintended consequences and, in the worst cases — contrary to their own intentions — do more harm than good.

That is why Jen Ford Reedy urges the sector to think differently about risk.

“There are two kinds of risk, I’d say, from a grantmaking perspective. One is that the thing doesn’t work. And the other is that whether or not it works, it causes harm,” she says.

The problem is that many people bring their conventional understanding of risk management with them into the foundation boardroom.

“When you’re doing risk management in your organization, it’s just about what harm is going to happen to the organization, right? Will we get sued? Will we lose donors? Will we lose customers? Will people want to work here?”

In philanthropy, the equation is different.

“Organizational risk in grantmaking is so low. I mean, you can hardly measure how low it is,” Jen Ford Reedy says.

If a grant does not work, the foundation is disappointed. The money has been spent and the intended change did not happen.

But the serious risk lies elsewhere.

“There is still a whole lot of risk in philanthropy. It’s just that other people bear it.”

And according to Reedy, that changes the entire way foundations should think about risk management.

“If they come into philanthropy without understanding that most of the risk is borne by other people, then they’re likely to massively overestimate the risk to the foundation and way underestimate the risk to other people,” Jen Ford Reedy says.

This can take the form of short-term grants or funding models in which grantees receive all or part of the money only after completing the project and incurring the expenses.

With short-term grants, an organization may find it harder to attract the right employees because it can only offer short-term contracts. The foundation has limited its own commitment — but in doing so has pushed the uncertainty onto the organization that has to carry out the work.

“That’s done nothing to mitigate any real risk to the foundation,” Jen Ford Reedy says.

In fact, the consequence can be the opposite.

“The foundation believes it feels like they’re managing their own risks responsibly. What they’ve actually done is increase the risk of failure of the work because they’ve exacerbated the risk and the difficulty for the grantee,” she says.

Turning the Risk Logic Around

At the Bush Foundation, Jen Ford Reedy and her board approach risk very differently.

How do you talk about risk?

“As one of our best assets,” Jen Ford Reedy says.

The foundation’s ability to bear risk is enormous compared with many of the organizations and people it funds, she explains.

So the question shifts from how the foundation can protect itself from risk to how it can take on risk for others.

“Our capacity for risk is huge,” Jen Ford Reedy says.

One example is the Bush Foundation’s work with SAGE Development Authority, the Standing Rock Sioux Tribe’s renewable-energy authority, on the large Anpetu Wi wind farm.

To retain the project’s place in the queue for connection to the electric grid, it needed a financial guarantee estimated at $30 million. Rather than leave Standing Rock to bear that risk alone, the Bush Foundation backed the guarantee with its own assets.

That is precisely the kind of situation Jen Ford Reedy looks for.

“We will always consider any way that we could de-risk things. And that includes putting up our assets to guarantee things,” she says.

That way of thinking can also change the discussion about the size of the grant itself.

At Bush Foundation board meetings, the question regularly comes up:

“Shouldn’t we be giving more?”

“The conversation is not about minimizing our investment. It is about improving the odds of success,” Jen Ford Reedy says.

“Then you start thinking, okay, are we doing enough? Could we do more to actually make that work a success?”

Learn to Notice When You’re Wrong

There is no single right way to be a foundation, according to Jen Ford Reedy.

She is agnostic about the philanthropic model, as long as the philanthropist understands the choices being made and their consequences — and is willing to learn.

Because much of the bad philanthropy she sees has one thing in common: the people practicing it do not realize they are doing it badly.

“In a lot of cases, people believe they’re doing it well because they’re not getting the feedback or they’re not getting the feedback in a way that makes them question what they’re doing,” Jen Ford Reedy says.

If a grantee tells a foundation that one-year grants are making the work more difficult, the board may conclude that the grantee simply does not understand the foundation.

But it could also choose to ask whether the quality of its philanthropy is as high as the foundation itself believes.

In the introduction to her book, Jen Ford Reedy poses two core questions:

  • Are you good at philanthropy?
  • How do you know?

That is why Jen Ford Reedy returns again and again to learning. Only by listening and learning can you become good at giving money away.

“If you were going to say the most important thing about being effective, it’s having that feedback loop so that you can learn and improve,” Jen Ford Reedy says.

Which brings us back to the woman from North Dakota. She was asked how the Bush Foundation could do better.

Jen Ford Reedy listened to her answer.

And then she wrote a book.

Mere du kan læse:

Impact Insider skriver om samfundsforandring til mennesker på tværs af sektorer.
Fortæl os om dig selv, så vi kan vise dig det mest relevante indhold.

Jeg besøger Impact Insider som


Og hvis du ikke vil gå glip af noget, kan du i stedet klikke på: